Trust Shields You When Elephants Fight with Naphtali Hoff (Throwback)

From Transformative Principal · Hosted by Jethro Jones

Sep 28, 2025·1410

Episode summary

In this episode of Transformative Principal: Executive coach Naphtali Hoff, author of Becoming the New Boss, explains how to win teacher buy in as a new school leader. He says everything flows from the foundation of trust, because staff who trust you forgive mistakes and will change the vision before they ask for a new leader. Hoff describes arriving at a school built by a long-serving principal and moving too fast, which meant repair work in his first and second years.

Original publisher description

Executive coach Naphtali Hoff, author of Becoming the New Boss, explains how to win teacher buy in as a new school leader. He says everything flows from the foundation of trust, because staff who trust you forgive mistakes and will change the vision before they ask for a new leader. Hoff describes arriving at a school built by a long-serving principal and moving too fast, which meant repair work in his first and second years. Jethro Jones adds a story about a superintendent who congratulated his wife on Facebook, and Hoff then lays out the ABCD trust model: able, believable, connected, dependable. What you'll learn Own a rushed change in front of your staff, as Hoff did, speaking to teachers publicly and in small groups to ask for their backing.Build the foundation of trust, relationships and listening before you push a mandate, so you spend less time repairing damage with adults.Ask whether staff support you and your vision, since trust in you can turn "get another leader" into "get another vision."Check yourself against able, believable, connected and dependable, and work on the one you touch least.Make small personal connections, like a congratulations note, because people decide with emotion first. Chapters 3:43 How to come back from a leadership mistake7:33 Urgency versus building the foundation first9:35 Supporting the leader versus supporting the vision11:24 Why decisions follow emotional connection15:26 The ABCD model of trust18:22 Invest in yourself because you can't give what you don't have Questions this episode answers How do you come back from a mistake as a new principal? Hoff says he moved too quickly to raise discipline and professionalism in a veteran school without enough trust building. He spent his first and second years on repair work and spoke publicly and individually to teachers to own his mistakes and ask for their support. Why do teachers resist a new principal's vision? Hoff cites John Maxwell's idea that staff may support the vision but not the leader, or the leader but not the vision. If they don't back you, the answer is get another leader. If they trust you, it becomes get another vision. What are the four elements of trust in leadership? Hoff shares the Ken Blanchard Companies model, ABCD. Able means you can get the job done. Believable means you act with integrity. Connected means you care and listen. Dependable means you follow through. A leader does not have to be perfect in all four. About Naphtali Hoff Executive coach, organizational consultant, trainer, writer and speaker, and author of Becoming the New Boss. Links and resources Naphtali Hoff on Twitter Working on this at your school? Get a free preview of a 10-week leadership pathway built from episodes like this one at transformativeprincipal.com/start.