Redesign Tier 1 Instruction for Deeper Learning with Michael Toth

From Transformative Principal · Hosted by Jethro Jones

Nov 16, 2025·3250

Episode summary

In this episode of Transformative Principal: Michael Toth, founder and CEO of an instructional research company, makes the case for redesigning Tier 1 instruction around student teams. He says teacher-centered lessons no longer fit students shaped by screens and by a pandemic that taught them school is optional. His research center reports less misbehavior, higher attendance and closed achievement gaps.

Original publisher description

Michael Toth, founder and CEO of an instructional research company, makes the case for redesigning Tier 1 instruction around student teams. He says teacher-centered lessons no longer fit students shaped by screens and by a pandemic that taught them school is optional. His research center reports less misbehavior, higher attendance and closed achievement gaps. Toth describes what he sees on classroom walks: when low-performing schools name behavior as their top issue, he finds boring instruction. His fix is mixed-ability teams with roles and discussion protocols, and tasks set slightly above current level, like a trainer adding five pounds. His question for principals at the door is who is doing the work. What you'll learn Stop at a classroom door and ask who is working harder, the teacher or the student, and whose voice is dominant.Form mixed-ability teams instead of ability groups, with interdependent tasks, discussion protocols, team norms and roles like facilitator and learning monitor.Set tasks slightly above students' current level, and give them a toolbox of strategies to move from unproductive to productive struggle.Pick priority standards and spend less time on supporting standards, since Toth says covering every standard would take about 25 years.Treat AI as a research tool, not a way to write papers or summarize text, so students keep doing the thinking. Chapters 0:00 Education is about developing students, not just teaching3:44 Screen time and device-centric development7:17 How the pandemic changed students and made school optional14:38 Student teams cut misbehavior and close gaps21:19 Mixed-ability teams, roles and productive struggle32:18 The baseball study and shared background knowledge41:17 What rigor really means and the rigor walk50:15 One thing to do this week at the door Questions this episode answers What does rigor actually mean in the classroom? Toth says rigor is not harder questions, more work or more memorization. It is the complexity of the thinking a task requires, set slightly above where students are now so they work through productive struggle. His rigor walk checks the level of thinking students are doing. Why are mixed-ability teams better than ability groups? Toth says his research shows ability groups are the worst choice. Mixed-ability teams with interdependent tasks, protocols, norms and roles let students share background knowledge and tutor each other, which he says a teacher cannot personalize alone when a math class spans five to six grade levels. Is student misbehavior really a behavior problem? Toth says low-performing schools tell him behavior is their top issue, but when he walks classrooms he finds boring instruction. He links today's misbehavior to developmental gaps from screen time and says structured student teams brought misbehavior down dramatically. About Michael Toth Founder and CEO of a company that runs an applied research center on instruction, and author of The Power of Student Teams with David Sousa. Links and resources Michael Toth on student agency, 2022The Baseball ExperimentInstructional Empowerment rigor walkLibrary for deeper learningMichael Toth on LinkedInMichael Toth on XInstructional Empowerment Working on this at your school? Get a free preview of a 10-week leadership pathway built from episodes like this one at transformativeprincipal.com/start. Thanks to our Sponsor Broadcast Made Easy who help you start a news broadcast at your school by having everything you need in one easy-to-download place. Check it out today and get your kids creating. We’re proud to be sponsored by IXL. IXL’s comprehensive teaching and learning platform for math, language arts, science, and social studies is accelerating achievement in 95 of the top 100 U.S. school districts. Loved by teachers and backed by independent research from Johns Hopkins University, IXL can help you do the following and more: Simplify and streamline technologySave teachers’ timeReliably meet Tier 1 standardsImprove student performance on state assessments 🚀 Ready to see why leading districts trust IXL for their educational needs? Visit IXL.com/BE today to learn more about how IXL can elevate your school or district.